Back when Shion and I took Scott’s Pizza Tour in December I had asked Scott if he was a margherita pizza “snob” since that was the original pizza. He quickly put me in my place! First, he informed me that at some places, they are known for a specific pizza and maybe not for their margherita, so while it can be a good judge of a “base” pizza don’t only judge a pizzeria by it’s margherita pizza. Before you visit, find out if it’s known for a specific type of pizza. Second, margherita pizza’s were not the original pizza. The original pizza was dough, lard and cheese! He informed Shion and I that Keste’s, across the street from John’s Pizzeria on Bleeker, still sold the “original” pizza.
This past Sunday Shion and I made a lunch date to finally go to Keste’s and be brave and try the original pizza. We also ordered a Margherita pizza, because, well I’m not going to lie, I was concerned we weren’t going to like it and wanted a back up plan!
The margherita was amazing!!!! I mean look at it. It was just melt in your mouth delicious. I thought it was just as good as a Lombardi’s or maybe even John’s (em…maybe not, John’s is saltier and I love that about it!) Amano’s in Ridgewood, NJ (my home town) another recommendation by Scott, is certainly just as good as Keste. (Side note: I’ve gotten my parents seriously addicted to Amano’s!)
YUM!!!! So before I dove in to this mouthwatering delicacy (well, hey I’m in NYC, pizza is a delicacy here!) I tried a small sliver of the lard pizza, or rather the Mastunicola (that sounds nicer).
I have to say, I thought it was just OK! I think for me it was a big mind over matter thing. I couldn’t stop thinking about it and so that made it less enjoyable. It was almost as if they had melted crisco and poured that on the dough, covered it in cheese and then put some fatty bacon on it. It was nice and salty but I just couldn’t get over – well the lard! I’m certainly glad I tried it, it’s always good to try new things, but I think Shion liked it more than me! We split the margherita pizza and she enjoyed more of the Mastinucola.
I will say though that I L.O.V.E.D. Keste Pizzeria & Vino. We were greeted in Italian, the place was small and cozy but decorated very warmly. The pizza oven was at the back of the restaurant and you could see them making your pizza. I think this is the place that the Italians in NYC go! Everyone around us knew the staff and they were all speaking in Italian. I loved, loved, loved that! I’m certainly looking forward to going back and trying some of their other pizzas. It’s fun to find warm, personal, neighborhood places in NYC.
This was another great recommendation from Scott…I think it’s time Shi and I took a bus tour! Pizza here we come…. If you want to read Shion’s review, click here!
Post in Comments:
What is your favorite pizza topping? I personally am a huge Margherita pizza fan but if I had to put a topping on it would definitely be red onions and crumbled sausage!



















